Power Lines Tangled by Red Tape
India sees demand for electricity surge, but puts off foreign investors; Enron waits
India needs more power - megawatts of it. But you wouldn't know it by the way eager foreign investors are treated.
A year after the Maharashtra state government stopped construction on one electric project involving Houston-based Enron Corp., work still hasn't restarted. Enron and fellow investors in the Dabhol Power Company - General Electric Company and International Generating Company - await a judgment from the Mumbai High Court dismissing public-interest petitions that seek to scuttle the mammoth project.
It isn't just foreign companies that are dissatisfied with India's electricity market. One reason for such delays, in fact, is complaints that consumers are being gouged.
"If governments had awarded the first power projects using competitive bidding, it may have led to some delays. Yet it could have prevented the constant criticism that the power policy and projects have been subjected to," says M.P. Abraham, Secretary of India's Ministry of Power.
For Enron and other shareholders in the $2.5 billion Dabhol Power plant, this criticism has resulted in having to fight 13 court cases against the project.
That's on top of the 2,015 megawatt project's outright cancelation a year ago by the newly elected government in Maharashtra state. Its Hindu fundamentalist leaders alleged the contract was too costly and involved government corruption.
By January, the state had negotiated a fresh contract with the company, lowering the project's cost. The government now admits it has no evidence of corruption.
"The cancelation was just political posturing. When the new government realized that it would have to pay huge damages if it violated Dabhol's contract, it changed tack," says one banker here.