Menu
Share
Share this story
Close X
 
Switch to Desktop Site

Chile's justice in world glare if Britain lets Pinochet go

Other countries may take a cue if Chile, as expected, fails to try theformer dictator. London rules soon.

About these ads

Chilean human rights leaders cheered Britain's arrest of former Gen. Augusto Pinochet in October.

Now, in two or three weeks, House of Lords judges are expected to decide whether the ex-dictator has diplomatic immunity and can thus escape extradition to a Spanish court. If he becomes free to go home, human rights leaders in Chile warn, Mr. Pinochet will never stand trial in his own country for the human rights violations charged to his 17-year regime.

The reason is Chile's legal system, which is chock-full of laws and loopholes to prevent that scenario from occurring. Further, there is immense pressure in Chilean society from rightist and military leaders against prosecuting Pinochet.

Other countries may take a cue from Chile and seek to sacrifice justice on human rights issues in order to achieve reconciliation in their national life.

"It is unthinkable that Pinochet can go to jail. The Chilean government ... says that he can be tried in Chile, but there is no way to do that," says Felipe Portales, project director at the Chilean Commission on Human Rights and a former director of human rights policy in Chile's government.

Fifteen criminal lawsuits accusing Pinochet of human rights violations are currently being investigated by Chilean magistrate Juan Guzman. But Mr. Portales says that Mr. Guzman may carry out his investigations to the end, perhaps even interrogate Pinochet, but none of the cases will ever reach a Chilean court.

Here are the hurdles in the way:

*According to Chile's amnesty law, all human rights crimes committed between Sept. 11, 1973, and March 10, 1978, are immune from prosecution.

*The prescription law is a common-law Chilean statute stating that crimes committed more than 15 years prior to a present date cannot be prosecuted.

*As part of Chile's Constitution enacted in 1980, designed with the guiding hand of Pinochet, all former heads of state of at least six years are afforded the privilege of being a senator-for-life in Chile's Congress. As a senator, Pinochet has immunity that can be removed only by a majority vote of the Chilean Senate.

Portales says that the lone bright spot in the legal web insulating Pinochet from prosecution was a decision by a lower court in September 1998 that says the Geneva Conventions - protecting civilians from torture, for example - have precedence over Chilean laws. However, Portales says that, in four other cases after that ruling, the courts said the conventions did not have precedence over Chilean laws.

Next

Page:   1   |   2


Follow Stories Like This
Get the Monitor stories you care about delivered to your inbox.

Loading...