No bail for illegal immigrants?
A new Arizona law that denies bond to suspected illegal immigrants charged with crimes faces its first legal challenge Tuesday.
An Arizona state judge recently denied bond to Melvin Omar Hernandez because he believes Mr. Hernandez is an illegal immigrant and, thus, a flight risk.
It's a step unique to Arizona, which has a new law – approved by 78 percent of voters here in November – that essentially denies bail to suspected illegal immigrants who've probably committed serious crimes. Known locally as Proposition 100, it is intended to make sure those suspects stay in jail and face criminal charges rather than slipping across the southern border to avoid prosecution or getting deported by federal immigration officials.
But Hernandez is not a flight risk, his lawyers argue, and so the judge's ruling violates the spirit of Proposition 100. After all, Hernandez was arrested merely for possessing fake documents, and he willingly – without incarceration or police transport – turned up for two court hearings after his arrest, they note. The defense team is petitioning the state appeals court to reverse the judge's ruling, but it is also challenging the very constitutionality of Proposition 100 itself.
The appeals court is slated to hear arguments in the case Tuesday. It's not clear how soon a ruling will come or how many of the thorny issues surrounding Proposition 100 it will ultimately resolve. But no one expects that the matter will fade anytime soon, given the explosion of controversy over the new law this spring.
For one thing, there are at least 95 other people in Arizona in the same boat as Hernandez, with more on the way – and some of them may also emerge as test cases of the new law. For another, all sides in the battle over immigration perceive too much at stake to let it rest.
Advocates of Proposition 100 say it is in Arizona's interest to prosecute hardened criminals to the full extent of the law, and to do that the state needs to prevent them from retreating to Mexico or other countries of origin. Moreover, it is a potential way to collect data that have long been in short supply: the number of serious or violent crimes committed by undocumented immigrants.