Can you inherit an e-book?(Read article summary)
Passing on your favorite books to your heirs has sentimental value. But how will that work if your library is digital?
AP Photo/Mark Lennihan, File
In settling the estate of my Aunt Eunice, who died recently at 94, her nieces and nephews gathered at her house a few months ago to divide her things, including her personal library.
Tim, my oldest brother, got Eunice‚Äôs bird books. He‚Äôs been carrying them into the yard on mild mornings, comparing the birds in the pages with the birds in the branches, testing literature against life.
I got Eunice‚Äôs Plutarch, her English poetry, and the many coffee-table books about her favorite artist, Andrew Wyeth. I knew little about Wyeth before these volumes dropped in my lap. But thanks to this unexpected gift,¬†¬†I‚Äôve been spending my evenings trailing Wyeth across one wheat-colored landscape after another, learning what all the fuss is about.
When Eunice‚Äôs books passed from one household to another, what we inherited, I suppose, was a particular way of seeing things, an intimate philosophy. That‚Äôs what a personal library is, I guess: an assortment of books that have survived successive purgings of the shelves over the years, leaving only the ideas and insights a reader truly treasures. To open these books is to remember what Eunice loved, and to indulge the possibility that they might attract our affection, too.
This is largely how literary tradition has been built over the years ‚Äď in the physical passage of books from one generation to the next, the choosing of what to hold dear and what to discard. The books that a succession of descendants decides to keep become, through stubborn resilience, the works we call classics.
But I‚Äôve been wondering, as I look at the books that once stood on Eunice‚Äôs shelves and now stand on mine, how all of this is going to work in the world of digital publishing. I don‚Äôt want to sound dismissive of e-books, which have some distinct advantages over traditional books. But it‚Äôs not quite the same, I imagine, to discover, upon the death of a loved one, that you‚Äôre the proud owner of the dear departed‚Äôs e-reader. A digital library seems much too fragile to constitute a true bequeathing of a body of knowledge. One cannot easily envision an heirloom download of a John Updike novel, for example,¬†passing from father to son to grandson.
This question has become more vivid to me as I consider not only the books I‚Äôve inherited over the years, but the volumes I might leave behind. At age 49, I‚Äôm looking forward to many more years of happy reading, but the approach of the half-century mark makes one think, with sharpened urgency, of estate planning.
I doubt that I‚Äôll reread my copies of Willa Cather‚Äôs ‚ÄúDeath Comes for the Archbishop‚ÄĚ and ‚ÄúMy Antonia,‚ÄĚ but I keep them around, at least partly, for the prospect that my son and daughter might eventually read them. I hold onto our ‚ÄúCurious George‚ÄĚ omnibus as a treasure for grandchildren yet unborn. And I hope, in some future year, that a descendant of mine will like my copy of E.B. White‚Äôs ‚ÄúOne Man‚Äôs Meat‚ÄĚ as much as I do.
But the simple truth is that my kids don‚Äôt seem very interested in the books that cover a wall of our living room. My teen-age daughter appears indifferent to them, and my 12-year-old son, although an avid reader, prefers to sample his dystopian fiction on a Kindle.
That‚Äôs left another question as I go about my usual cleaning, weeding my bookshelves and deciding what to keep for me, and those who come after me. Lately I‚Äôve been asking myself, as I dust off the keepers and return them to the bookcase: Will anyone really want this when I‚Äôm gone?