Colleges cope as endowments pinch
Budgets are cut as a new study reports an average loss of 23 percent in endowment value.
Courtesy of Amby Ghebretinsae/Rose Art Museum
College endowment funds, like other investments, took a huge hit this fall – resulting in billions of dollars less to spend on school budgets that cover everything from staff to building projects to student financial aid.
For colleges that rely on income from their endowments to fund a third or more of their operating expenses, cost-cutting measures, including layoffs and hiring freezes at some schools, are already under way.
If there's any good news for higher education, it could be that only a small number of colleges rely heavily on endowments to keep themselves running – and that college endowment funds in general performed better in the bear market than did the major indexes.
Still, between July 1 and Nov. 30, 2008, endowments lost nearly 23 percent of their value, according to a survey of 435 colleges and universities for a report released Tuesday by the National Association of College and University Business Officers (NACUBO) in Washington.
"For a small number of colleges, endowments have a very significant impact," says Sandy Baum, a senior policy analyst at the College Board, a nonprofit association in New York. Among the majority of colleges, which have smaller endowments, "the silver lining to not having a large endowment is [they're] not very dependent on it."
Despite the losses, most institutions, particularly those with large endowments, are expected to make financial aid a top priority. "There's a lot of hiring freezes or slowdowns going on, but ... student financial aid is one of those things, in bad economic times, where you don't want to reduce support," says John Walda, NACUBO's president and CEO.
Harvard, Princeton, Yale, and Dartmouth, for instance, all draw more than a third of their operating budgets from their multibillion-dollar endowments, but they've announced their intent to maintain financial aid – including relatively new policies to give more help to low- and middle-income families.
Less of a tuition increase
Princeton has gone a step further on affordability: On Monday, it announced its lowest undergraduate tuition and fee increase since 1966 – 2.9 percent. Next year's charges will top $47,000, but the average grant to students on financial aid is nearly $34,000. Also, Princeton is increasing its undergraduate scholarship budget by 13 percent.
"Even though [Princeton is] much less wealthy than before, they're not going to try to compensate for that through tuition increases," Ms. Baum says. "We don't know yet how many other similarly fortunate institutions are going to do that, but it wouldn't be surprising if they take that approach."
Many colleges will have trustee meetings in the coming months before determining tuition. "How you proceed on the tuition side and the financial aid side is going to have a very big impact on families' willingness to enroll.... But because the economic markets are so unstable, it's very hard for institutions to make plans with any certainty," says Terry Hartle, a senior vice president at the American Council on Education, a research and advocacy group in Washington.
Like many of its peers, Dartmouth College in Hanover, N.H., is facing an unprecedented budget situation in the wake of an 18 percent decline in its endowment from July to December. That brought the value down $700 million, to about $3 billion. The school relies on endowment spending for about 35 percent of its undergraduate college's operations.
Dartmouth officials recently announced that "some staff layoffs are inevitable" to help trim more than $60 million from the annual $700 million budget for its undergraduate college and professional schools. Tenured and tenure-track faculty and student financial aid are not subject to cuts. Just more than 70 out of 600 eligible nonfaculty employees have taken retirement incentives.
"It's a little bit somber," says executive vice president Adam Keller of the mood at Dartmouth. But people aren't surprised that layoffs are coming, and the community is working together to minimize the need for them, he adds. "We have more than 300 suggestions from employees about ... things we could do to save money, and we're looking at those very seriously."
The University of Rhode Island Foundation has seen an 18 percent decline, too, from its June 30 value of about $88 million. But the impact is small relative to schools with large endowments. It marked the median point of the NACUBO survey, with half the endowments higher and half lower. Typically, the endowment contributes about $4 million to the $308 million operating budget for the public university.
"There's a possibility that we won't be able to award any of that $4 million in the next fiscal year," says foundation president Glen Kerkian. It won't be clear until the end of the foundation's fiscal year in March how much it can award, and whether the university will be able to bridge the gap with other revenue. "Almost 55 percent [of endowment spending] is for scholarships.... This is what makes this like a double whammy.... Scholarships are as needed, and possibly as unavailable, as they've ever been," Mr. Kerkian says.
Spending part of an endowment
As endowments have enjoyed strong returns over the past several years, Sen. Charles Grassley (R) of Iowa has raised the idea of forcing colleges to spend a certain amount of their endowments – perhaps 5 percent – to help reduce costs for students. Now the pressure may be off.
"The whole idea of endowments is ... [to] have security for the long run and continue your operations in bad times," Baum says. So it's "totally appropriate" for schools with large endowments to spend at a lower rate in periods of rapid enrollment growth and to raise the rate in a downturn.
Over the past 10 years, the NACUBO survey has seen average annual spending rates ranging from 4.5 to 5.1 percent.