Share this story
Close X
Switch to Desktop Site

Letters to the Editor

Readers write about whether the Kindle compliments printed books, or will someday make them obsolete.

About these ads

Kindle: A 'Trojan horse' or a welcome tool?

Regarding the March 18 Opinion piece, "Kindle e-reader: A Trojan horse for free thought": I have to disagree with author Emily Walshe's opinion about the Kindle reader. Anything that expands access to books is a good, not a bad, thing.

I don't own the library books I read, but I don't buy them either. Books read on Kindle generate income for publishers and authors, not just for Amazon. And buyers can request additions to the Kindle list, which is already larger than the average bookstore's stock. What's more, with a Kindle, one can read in many more places and carry books wherever one goes. True. The books I buy on Kindle can't be passed on, but they are mine forever – or at least as long as I want to keep the reader.

The Kindle will never replace printed books; it is an addition to them. As such, it should be welcomed, not denigrated.

Emily Walshe is off the mark in much of her commentary on the Kindle. Kindle allows users to own files of their books, and they are free to back up those files on their computers. In addition, Kindle owners download paid content through Amazon, but can also download thousands of other books from a number of online sources free of charge.




Emily Walshe has framed a critically important issue. As she asserts, we are all too willing to accept digital commodification of thought without considering how that commodification affects our private and public thinking. We need to think through how access to digital information changes and restricts our use of that information.

Thanks for a provocative commentary.

The commentary raises some important questions about the nature of how we access information. Unfortunately, she seems to take a Luddite perspective on it, claiming that we need a physical record that anyone can have permanent access to.


Page:   1   |   2

Follow Stories Like This
Get the Monitor stories you care about delivered to your inbox.