Menu
Share
Share this story
Close X
 
Switch to Desktop Site

Supreme Court and health care law: state sovereignty at stake

The Supreme Court hears various challenges to the health-care law next week. While the individual mandate will be the focus, state sovereignty is also at stake, especially in state reform of health care.

Image

Justices of the Supreme Court gather for a group portrait. Seated from left are Clarence Thomas, Antonin Scalia, John Roberts, Anthony M. Kennedy, and Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Standing, from left are Sonia Sotomayor, Stephen Breyer, Samuel Alito Jr., and Elena Kagan.

Pablo Martinez Monsivais/AP Photo/File

About these ads

Next week, the US Supreme Court holds three days of hearings on challenges to the health-care law signed by President Obama two years ago. Much of the focus will be on the law’s mandate that individuals must buy private insurance or be fined. But an equally compelling issue is whether the law violates the sovereignty of states.

Just as individuals have rights under the Constitution, states are granted all powers not given to Congress, such as police powers, under the 10th Amendment. The new law erodes that sovereignty in many ways, such as requiring states to spend more on Medicaid. But its biggest impact may be that it hinders the states’ ability to offer alternatives paths to universal health care by not allowing them to exempt their citizens from the mandate.

Since the law’s passage, 14 states have passed measures to guarantee the freedom of their citizens not to buy health insurance. And 26 states are party to the legal challenges to the law. This shows a rigorous assertion of the argument that local government is the best government, especially in the face of a federal law that aims to control an industry that makes up 17 percent of the economy.

In fact, while the high court will try to balance competing federal and state powers in its coming ruling (expected in June), the issue may not be strictly constitutional but rather the best way Americans can change their society in regard to difficult topics such as access to health care.

Next

Page:   1   |   2


Follow Stories Like This
Get the Monitor stories you care about delivered to your inbox.

Loading...