Share this story
Close X
Switch to Desktop Site

Court reinstates EPA clean-air rule

(Read article summary)

Michael Bryant/Philadelphia Inquirer/MCT

(Read caption) A federal appeals court reinstated a Bush administration rule that seeks to cap harmful emissions in Eastern US states, such as the ones spewing out of this oil refinery on the Delaware River.

About these ads

A federal appeals court on Tuesday temporarily reinstated a Bush administration rule that sought to cut harmful pollution from power plants and other facilities in the Eastern US.

Issued in 2005 and set to take effect on Jan. 1, the Clean Air Interstate Rule permanently capped emissions of sulfur dioxide and nitrogen oxides in 28 Eastern and Midwestern states. The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) says that the rule would prevent about 17,000 deaths a year and save up to $100 billion in health benefits.

But this past July, following a lawsuit against the EPA by North Carolina and some electric power producers, the US Appeals Court for the District of Columbia Circuit threw out the rule, citing what it called “more than several fatal flaws” in the regulation. The judges believed that the EPA was improperly interfering with pollution permit trading markets and unfairly privileging coal utilities over natural-gas ones.

That ruling managed to disappoint environmentalists, the White House, and many power companies that had invested billions in anticipation of a more robust trading market that would have arisen under the rule.

But after hearing the case again, the DC court reversed its decision, allowing the rule to stay in place until the next administration fixes it.

The court did not issue a timetable, but, as the Associated Press reports, it warned the EPA that its ruling does not constitute an "indefinite stay" of its July decision.


Page:   1   |   2

Subscribe to Recharge
Get the Monitor stories you care about delivered to your inbox.