Share this story
Close X
Switch to Desktop Site

If humans didn't cause global warming and cooling in the past, is that evidence they also aren't now?

(Read article summary)


(Read caption) A receding glacier in Southern Greenland is one of many that has retreated (melted) dramatically since the end of the Little Ice Age (about 1850).

About these ads

The Medieval Warm Period (MWP) is a seemingly warmer-than-average 500 hundred years (very roughly 800 to 1300 AD) centered around the North Atlantic. During this period of slightly higher temperatures, the Vikings first colonized Greenland (the 980s), and established an ultimately ill-fated colony in today's Newfoundland, which they called Vinland.

Following the MWP came what's called the Little Ice Age (LIA), a dip in temperatures centered around the north Atlantic that ended in the mid-1800s.

(Here's a graphic of the MWP and the LIA from Wikimedia Commons with the multiple proxy data sources listed.)

These days, the MWP is often cited as evidence that, because the world was warmer in the past, the warming of recent decades is 1) hardly anomalous, 2) can't be the result of higher concentrations of carbon dioxide since the world warmed when CO2 was at pre-industrial levels, and 3) can't possibly be the result of human activity since humans were clearly not responsible for warming in medieval times.

These arguments bear some examination.

First, scientists think that the medieval warming period was a local phenomenon centered on the north Atlantic and a few other regions, and not global.

In other words, the whole world did not grow warmer during medieval times. Some areas appear to have been cooler. And while some areas seem to have experienced warmth comparable to today's, much evidence indicates that the global average was still lower than today's.


Page 1 of 4

Subscribe to Recharge
Get the Monitor stories you care about delivered to your inbox.