Share this story
Close X
Switch to Desktop Site

Is there dark matter in the sun? (+video)

A discrepancy between seismological and spectrographic observations of the sun could potentially be reconciled by dark matter, say scientists.

Super Collider upgrades may help scientists get closer to finding dark matter

Dark matter may be one of the greatest mysteries of the universe, but it could help solve a puzzle about the sun that has been baffling scientists for years, researchers say.

The mystery has to do with a seeming discrepancy in the composition of the sun, which experiences sound waves that zip around inside it and cause tiny rhythmic fluctuations in its brightness. By studying this flickering, scientists can better understand its composition and internal activity. This scientific field — known as helioseismology when it refers to the study of the sun, and asteroseismology when it refers to that of stars — is akin to seismology on Earth, which helps geologists yield insights into the innards of this planet.

About these ads

Elements in the sun heavier than hydrogen and helium influence how sound waves travel within the star. This means that, in principle, helioseismology can measure the abundance of each element with extremely high accuracy, said lead study author Aaron Vincent, an astroparticle physicist at Durham University in England.

Another way scientists can measure the abundance of each element in stars is by looking at their light, as each element gives off a unique fingerprint or spectrum of light. A decade or so ago, scientists discovered that light from the sun suggested that it had about 20 to 25 percent less carbon, nitrogen and oxygen than scientists had previously thought — a finding that contradicted what helioseismology had suggested. Existing models of the sun could not explain this discrepancy — a mystery that scientists call the solar abundance problem, Vincent said.

"Despite a decade of effort, this is a puzzle that has yet to be solved," Vincent said. "So far, no attempt to modify solar models to account for this discrepancy has really worked, which is what has prompted particle physicists to look for a more exotic explanation."

Dark matter to the rescue

Now, Vincent and his colleagues suggest that this solar mystery could be solved by dark matter, which in and of itself is one of the greatest mysteries in science.

Dark matter is an invisible and nearly intangible substance thought to make up about five-sixths of all matter in the universe. Scientists think dark matter is composed of a new type of particle — one that interacts very weakly, at best, with all the known forces of the universe and is mostly detectable only via the gravitational pull it exerts. However, many properties of dark-matter particles — such as their mass, and whether they annihilate themselves — remain uncertain. [Dark Matter: The Search in Images]

In 2011, Vincent was investigating ways in which dark matter might interact with other particles, when co-author Pat Scott, a researcher at Imperial College London, introduced him to the solar abundance problem.

Vincent thought dark matter "could be an interesting solution to the problem," Vincent recalled.

About these ads

The scientists ran thousands of simulations, looking at many different models of how dark matter might interact with the sun. They discovered a possible explanation for the solar abundance problem: A model suggested that dark matter is asymmetric, meaning one kind of dark-matter particle is more abundant than its antiparticle counterpart. Normal matter is asymmetric as well — for instance, there are far more protons than antiprotons in the universe.

"I think the most interesting aspect of this work is the potential link between two puzzles," Vincent said. On the one hand, there is the solar abundance problem, "which hints at a missing ingredient in our understanding of the sun, and on the other hand, this could be the very first hint about the particle nature of dark matter itself," he said. "It's exciting to think that we're looking at a link between such seemingly disconnected areas of physics."

The specific kind of asymmetric dark-matter particle that Vincent and his colleagues examined had a special property: The greater its momentum, the more likely it was that it would interact with other, normal particles. This finding suggests that "collisions that transfer more energy are more likely, and collisions that transfer less energy are suppressed," Vincent said.

Dark matter particle search

The physicists suggested that these asymmetric dark-matter particles could absorb energy in the hottest central part of the sun's core. The particles might then zip to a cooler part of the sun, where they could deposit this energy, and the changes in the sun that this would trigger might explain the solar abundance problem, the researchers said. They predict that such particles would have a mass of about 3 billion electron volts, or a little more than three times the mass of a proton. [Dark Matter: What Is It? (Infographic)]

The asymmetric-dark-matter model differs from those suggesting that dark-matter particles are their own antiparticles, and thus annihilate themselves when they make contact with one another.

"The main advantage of asymmetric dark matter is that a lot of it can accumulate in the sun as it speeds through the dark-matter cloud that engulfs the Milky Way," Vincent said. "If the dark matter was self-annihilating, the dark matter would disappear before transporting any sizable amount of heat from the sun's core."

If this asymmetricdark matter really does exist, "we should be on the cusp of seeing it very soon," Vincent said. He noted that it may be seen by next-generation dark-matter-detection experiments, such as SuperCDMS, located deep underground in the Soudan Mine in northern Minnesota, as well as during the next run of the Large Hadron Collider, the most powerful atom smasher in the world.

Vincent, Scott and their colleague Aldo Serenelli, of Spain's Institute of Space Sciences in Bellaterra,will detail their findings in a paper accepted for publication in the journal Physical Review Letters.

Follow us @Spacedotcom, Facebook and Google+. Original article on

Copyright 2015, a Purch company. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.

Follow Stories Like This
Get the Monitor stories you care about delivered to your inbox.