Texas judge refuses bid to make child porn users pay damages
A federal judge in Texas Monday sentenced a man to two years in prison for possession of child porn, but refused to make him pay $3.4 million in restitution to the girl in the pictures. Prosecuting lawyers called the ruling a setback for victims of child porn.
A federal judge has refused to order a Texas man to pay nearly $3.4 million in restitution to a girl depicted in photos of child pornography he downloaded from the Internet.
Doyle Randall Paroline did not know the girl whose picture he downloaded, and she knows nothing of him. But prosecutors urged the judge to order Mr. Paroline to pay full restitution for her injuries, including her sexual abuse by an uncle 12 years ago and the continued traffic in her photos on the web.
Paroline has been sentenced to serve two years in federal prison for possession of child pornography.
The Paroline restitution case in Tyler, Texas, was seen as an important test of a tough anti-child pornography law in which federal prosecutors were seeking to impose the same high level of restitution on those found in possession of child pornography as would be imposed against those who physically abused a child, photographed the abuse, and distributed the images.
Prosecutors argued that the injury to the girl was ongoing as a result of those who continue to download images of her abuse.
The judge agreed that the abuse was ongoing, but he decided that it did not justify holding a defendant in a possession case to the same level of financial responsibility as an individual who carried out the physical abuse and created the child pornography.
US District Judge Leonard Davis ruled on Monday that the government had failed to prove the precise nature of the injuries caused by the man's possession of two images of the girl.
Tough child pornography laws
Paroline admitted knowingly possessing on his computers more than 150 images of minors engaged in sexually explicit conduct. An analysis of those photos by the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children identified a girl referred to as "Amy."