Share this story
Close X
Switch to Desktop Site

Obama health care law at Supreme Court: mega case for the history books

Next Previous

Page 3 of 6

About these ads

In broad terms, the president and his supporters favor a central government strong enough to shape economic markets to advance their view of the collective good. They say the Constitution's Commerce Clause, which gives Congress the authority to pass laws regulating commerce and economic activity among the states, supports the individual mandate.

Republicans, who want a smaller, limited national government, say requiring an individual to purchase something is not legitimate Commerce Clause regulation.

Republicans attack the health-care law as a job killer and as an anchor around the neck of a still-wheezing economy. Democrats brush the attacks aside and defend the measure as a necessary reform to make health care more affordable to an estimated 50 million uninsured Americans.

The centerpiece of the law is its requirement that every American purchase health insurance.

This is a reasonable regulation, the president and other supporters say, because virtually everyone will, at some unpredictable moment, require medical care and hospitalization.

"No one is more than an instant from needing health care," Solicitor General Donald Verrilli wrote in his brief to the court.

Opponents attack the individual mandate as a solution to a problem of Congress's own making. The mandate, they say, is being used to assemble a broad enough pool of healthy Americans to underwrite expensive provisions in the bill – like the ban on insurance companies charging higher premiums for those with costly preexisting medical conditions.

They also say the mandate marks a sharp departure from traditions of American liberty and the Founders' concept of shared federal-state power.

They say if the federal government can simply order Americans to buy a product – like insurance for health care, or broccoli to support a healthy diet, or a Chevy to bail out the US auto industry – there is nothing Congress can't order citizens to do.

Next Previous

Page 3 of 6

Follow Stories Like This
Get the Monitor stories you care about delivered to your inbox.