Share this story
Close X
Switch to Desktop Site

Obama wins big on health-care law, but court ruling sure to energize GOP (+video)

US Supreme Court's decision vindicates President Obama's insistence that his health-care reform law is constitutional. The political cost: Republicans can tap into public dislike of the law. 

Speaker of the US House John Boehner reacts to the Supreme Court's decision on the health-care reform law.
About these ads

In upholding the mandate for individuals to purchase health insurance, the US Supreme Court has handed President Obama a huge election-year victory.

The mandate is the centerpiece of Mr. Obama’s Affordable Care Act (ACA) – the signature legislative accomplishment of his presidency, which aims to set the nation on a path to universal health-care coverage. With the court's 5-to-4 decision, Obama is vindicated in his insistence that the law is constitutional. Never mind that the court upheld the mandate in a manner few had expected: that the penalty for failing to buy insurance is a tax, which Congress has the right to levy.

As a former teacher of constitutional law, Obama would have faced embarrassment had the mandate been struck down.

But Obama’s victory could come at a political cost. The mandate is unpopular with the public, and the president will have to defend it in his reelection campaign. At the same time, the high court has handed his challenger, Mitt Romney, and the GOP a pungent election-year issue. Republicans, particularly those with a libertarian, tea party bent, assert that the mandate represents an overreach of federal power and an affront to individual liberty.

At press time, both Obama and Mr. Romney were due to deliver statements shortly.  


Page:   1   |   2

Follow Stories Like This
Get the Monitor stories you care about delivered to your inbox.