Marjah offensive: New Afghan governor takes office as battle rages
Less than two weeks into the Marjah offensive in Afghanistan, an Afghan governor flew into town on Monday and began holding meetings.
The shots havenâ€™t even died away in one of NATOâ€™s biggest offensives of its nine-year war in Afghanistan, but US State Department officials are already rushing in Afghan government staff as part of the ambitious next phase of Operation Moshtarak.
The speedy rollout in Marjah of the new US strategy to â€śclear, hold, and buildâ€ť is part of the renewed US strategy of wresting momentum from the Taliban. But some experts warn there is no way to install good government overnight.
Ten days into the fight â€“ with US Marines and their Afghan counterparts still advancing on Taliban fighters holed up in the north and west â€“ Marjahâ€™s new subdistrict governor was brought in and held a shura, or council, with local elders in the town center.
Haji Zahir will hold a flurry of similar meetings with other community representatives as soon as he is properly installed, possibly before the end of the week, in makeshift offices while the real ones are cleared of bombs and refurbished.
Civilian stabilization and governance advisers will assist him as he seeks to extend his reach as far and as quickly as possible. In the northern part of Nad-i-Ali, the district to which Marjah belongs, fighting has slackened sufficiently for development specialists to start rolling out â€śschools-in-a-box.â€ť Repairs to irrigation canals are also under way.
Window of opportunity
Everyone from lowly subdistrict administrators to the government ministries in Kabul is involved in planning Marjahâ€™s future, Western officials are keen to emphasize.
â€śWeâ€™ve planned to have all this in place very quickly partly because we â€“ the Afghan government and Western advisers â€“ feel like we have a window in which to win over the local population,â€ť says Bay Fang, a State Department spokesperson in southern Afghanistan.
â€śInstalling a subdistrict administrator along with governance and stabilization advisers allows the work of government to start straight away. Because basically we want to show the people that the government can deliver basic services and is a viable alternative to the Taliban.â€ť
According to the new population-centric counterinsurgency strategy championed by top commander Gen. Stanley McChrystal, the real battle for Marjah â€“ and for the rest of Afghanistan â€“ lies in governance and security, not gunfights.
Operation Moshtarak is â€śin many ways â€¦ a model for the future: an Afghan-led operation supported by the coalition, deeply engaged with the people,â€ť McChrystal told reporters on Sunday.
The rush to roll out a functioning local government may also reflect the tight deadline that coalition forces face in Afghanistan. Large amounts of territory remain to be cleared of insurgents, developed, and restored to Afghan sovereignty before President Barack Obamaâ€™s July 2011 deadline for a drawdown of US troops.
Operation Moshtarak is the first phase of an 18-month campaign plan mapped out by McChrystal. The focus of coalition and Afghan forces will soon switch to the neighboring province of Kandahar, where the Taliban movement spluttered to life in the early 1990s, and where power has traditionally resided in southern Afghanistan.
There, as in Marjah, troops will try to clear out the insurgents and install a new government. But the battle to win hearts and minds can be easily set back by civilian casualties. According to the Afghan government, a US airstrike on Sunday killed at least 27 civilians on the border of Uruzgan and Day Kundi Provinces â€“ NATOâ€™s third botched bombing raid in seven days. Afghan government ministers called the strike â€śunjustifiable.â€ť
Not everyone is convinced by the rapid effort to impart good governance in Marjah.
â€śIs [Operation Moshtarak] going to address one of the root causes of this insurgency â€“ bad governance and exclusionary politics? Thatâ€™s at the heart of it,â€ť says a Western analyst in Kabul, who asked to go unnamed.
â€śWhat can the West bring? More resources? Yes. Better politics? Unlikely,â€ť he says. â€śAt the end of the day people want local leaders they can trust. That canâ€™t be delivered overnight. That takes years. It isnâ€™t that this operation is without value but weâ€™ve got to get away from the idea that we can just parachute in a ready-made government.