Share this story
Close X
Switch to Desktop Site

On eve of Prince William wedding, some (former) aristocrats critique the royal mystique


Page 2 of 2

About these ads

Benjamin von Brackel, who says his family is “totally ‘embourgeoisified’ ” except for still retaining its coat of arms, says that even in Germany, where formal privilege was abolished long ago, aristocrats enjoy more influence than may people care to admit.

Mr. Von Brackel notes there are seven aristocrats in the German parliament, saying that this is a disproportionate number and thus exemplifies continuing power:

While Germany has a population of about 82 million people, there are estimated to be only 80,000-120,000 nobles. The aristocracy lost its legal status in 1945, the nobility in the GDR [East Germany] its property and much of the nobility their homes east of the Elbe. In the old Federal Republic [West Germany] the nobility managed to preserve itself as an exclusive group, and to keep its assets, palaces and its land.

Back on 'planet pleb' with the rest of us, journalist Stefanie Hardick, who says she is “nobody’s subject,” argues that European monarchs exert subtle but real pressure on politics and, despite attempts to paint themselves as just being families like any other, enjoy “privileges that go far beyond the rights of their subjects.”

The issue of cost also rears its head with the magazine noting a Dutch government study that found the country's monarchy cost the taxpayers €110 million euros (about $163 million) annually.

On the other hand, she says, countries with monarchies tend to have a stronger sense of identity:

Juan Carlos I is deemed the father of Spanish democracy. The German government spokesman Steffen Seibert referred to King Albert II recently as a symbol of the threatened unity of Belgium. And without the Grimaldis, Monaco would probably have ago long become a French province.


Page:   1   |   2

Follow Stories Like This
Get the Monitor stories you care about delivered to your inbox.