Iran talks: Serious and substantive, but without breakthrough
Despite a change in tone, this week's talks between Iran and six other nations, including the U.S., did not yield tangible results. The group will reconvene next month.
The¬†United States¬†described two days of nuclear negotiations with Iran¬†as the most serious and candid to date after Western diplomats said¬†Tehran¬†hinted it was ready to scale back sensitive atomic activities to secure urgent sanctions relief.
But a senior U.S. administration official told reporters after the conclusion of negotiations between Iran¬†and six world powers that no breakthroughs had been achieved and many disagreements remained. Other Western diplomats involved in the talks said there had been no apparent narrowing of differences between¬†Tehran¬†and the six nations over its nuclear ambitions.
"I've been doing this now for about two years," the official said on condition of anonymity. "And I have never had such intense, detailed, straightforward, candid conversations with the Iranian delegation before."
The¬†White House¬†spokesman,¬†Jay Carney, echoed the remarks, saying Iran's proposal showed "a level of seriousness and substance that we had not seen before". But he cautioned that "no one should expect a breakthrough overnight".
Washington's ally¬†Israel, which has told the¬†United States, Britain,¬†France,¬†Germany,¬†Russia¬†and¬†China¬†- the six nations negotiating with Iran¬†- not to trust¬†Tehran, said Prime Minister¬†Benjamin Netanyahu¬†plans to speak next week with U.S. Secretary of State¬†John Kerry¬†about the¬†Geneva¬†talks and sanctions should not be eased until Iran¬†proves it is dismantling its program.
Netanyahu on Oct. 1 told the¬†U.N. General Assembly Iran's new President Hassan Rouhani, widely seen as a pragmatist and centrist, was a "wolf in sheep's clothing" and that¬†Israel¬†was ready to act alone to keep¬†Tehran¬†from getting nuclear weapons.
Follow-up talks between the six powers and Iran¬†will be held in¬†Geneva¬†on Nov. 7-8.
Tehran¬†denies allegations by Western powers that it is seeking the capability to produce atomic bombs.
But so far it has defied U.N. Security Council demands that it halt enrichment and other sensitive nuclear activities, leading to multiple rounds of crippling international sanctions that have reduced Iranian oil exports, caused inflation to soar and the value of the Iranian rial currency to plummet.
Western officials have said that they need Iran¬†to increase the transparency of its nuclear programme, stop enriching uranium to 20 percent, reduce its uranium stockpiles and take other steps to assure the world it does not want atomic weapons.
In a rare joint statement highlighting the dramatic shift from confrontation to dialogue since Rouhani took office in August, negotiators from Iran¬†and the six world powers said¬†Tehran's new proposal aimed at defusing longstanding suspicions over the nature of its nuclear programme was an "important contribution" now under careful consideration.
Details of Iran's proposal, presented during two days of negotiations in¬†Geneva, have not been released, and Western officials were unsure whether¬†Tehran¬†was prepared to go far enough to clinch a breakthrough deal.
The joint statement, read out by¬†European Union¬†foreign policy chief¬†Catherine Ashton, said Iran's Foreign Minister¬†Mohammad Javad Zarif¬†"presented an outline of a plan as a proposed basis for negotiation" and the talks were "substantive and forward looking," without elaborating.
Zarif, who is also Iran's chief negotiator, said¬†Tehran¬†looked to a new era in diplomatic relations after a decade of tension, in which concerns about the Islamic state's nuclear ambitions fuelled fears of a new war in the¬†Middle East.
"We sense that members of the (six powers) also have exhibited the necessary political will in order to move the process forward. Now we need to get to the details," he told reporters after being brought into the auditorium in a wheelchair due to severe back pain.
After Tuesday's initial round, Iranian Deputy Foreign Minister¬†Abbas Araqchi¬†suggested¬†Tehran¬†was prepared to address long-standing calls for the U.N. nuclear watchdog to have wider and more intrusive inspection powers.
Araqchi met the head of the U.S. delegation, Undersecretary of State¬†Wendy Sherman, on Tuesday, the third bilateral contact between the two nations since Rouhani's election in June. They followed a telephone call between Rouhani and President Barack Obama last month, the highest level U.S.-Iranian contact since Iran's Islamic Revolution in 1979.
Washington cut off diplomatic ties with¬†Tehran¬†in 1980.
The sequencing of any concessions by Iran¬†and any sanctions relief by the West could prove a stumbling block en route to a landmark, verifiable deal. Western officials have repeatedly said that Iran¬†must suspend enriching uranium to 20 percent fissile purity, their main worry, before sanctions are eased.
Rouhani's election opened the door to serious negotiations with the six powers, Western envoys say.
Britain said it hoped this week's talks would lead to "concrete" results but that Iran¬†must take the initiative. "Iran¬†will need to take the necessary first steps on its programme and we are ready to take proportionate steps in return," Foreign Secretary¬†William Hague¬†said.
Russia¬†warned against undue optimism. "The result is better than in Almaty (talks held in April) but does not guarantee further progress,"¬†Sergey Ryabkov,¬†Russia's deputy foreign minister and Iran¬†negotiator, told Interfax. "There could have been better cooperation."
Complete halt to enrichment out of question¬†
Western diplomats were hesitant to divulge specifics about the negotiations due to sensitivities involved - both in¬†Tehran, where conservative hardliners are sceptical about striking deals that could curtail the nuclear programme, and in Washington, where hawks are reluctant to support swift sanctions relief.
In a sign of U.S. congressional skepticism, Senator Marco Rubio, seen as a potential 2016 Republican presidential nominee, introduced a non-binding resolution in the U.S. Senate arguing that current sanctions on Iran¬†must be kept and more added until¬†Tehran¬†"completely" abandons its suspected nuclear arms program.
Israel¬†on Wednesday also urged Western powers not to give up economic sanctions on¬†Iran until¬†Tehran¬†proves it is dismantling its nuclear program. "Iran should be tested by its actions, not its proposals," a senior Israeli official said on condition of anonymity in a message sent from Netanyahu's office.
But Iran, diplomats said, has made much more concrete proposals than in the past, when ideological lectures and obfuscations were the norm, to the point that Iranian negotiators were worried about details being aired in public before they had had a chance to sell them back in¬†Tehran.
Diplomats said other proposals Iranian envoys had made regarding eventual "confidence-building" steps included halting 20 percent enrichment and possibly converting at least some of existing 20 percent stockpiles - material that alarms the powers as it is only a short technical step away from weapons-grade - to uranium oxide suitable for processing into reactor fuel.
Iran has made clear for years that it does not intend to renounce uranium enrichment, despite U.N. Security Council demands that it do so.
Diplomats say the¬†United States¬†and its European allies have resigned themselves to the fact that¬†Tehran¬†will have to be allowed to maintain some enrichment capabilities, though the scale of its enrichment work will likely be the subject of heated negotiations in the coming months.
Western diplomats say that conceding to demands for zero Iranian enrichment from U.S. and Israeli hawks would undermine Rouhani's authority at home by exposing him to accusations of a sell-out from conservative hardliners in the clerical and security elite.
Most Iranians of whatever political persuasion equate the quest for nuclear energy with national sovereignty, modernisation and a standing equal to the Western world.