Keeping Palestinian Prisoners in View
Failure to grant an amnesty will fuel discontent about the peace process in occupied territories
PALESTINIANS in the occupied territories have yet to hear the news that most concerns them: the release of all their sons and brothers from Israeli prisons. When the Palestine Liberation Organization signed its accord with Israel in September, virtually every Palestinian family expected that freeing political prisoners would be among the first steps Israel would take to show its goodwill. It would be easy to implement and an important symbolic move, they thought.
``The release of prisoners should have been a precondition to the signing,'' says a West Bank man, a prisoner himself for five years. ``After all,'' notes another ex-prisoner, ``most of us were arrested because we were suspected members in a PLO party; now Israel's recognition of the PLO makes our detention invalid.''
This feeling runs deep. Arrests are so widespread under Israeli occupation that prison experience links the entire Palestinian population with a sense of common suffering and sacrifice. Almost every man over the age of 17 has been arrested and detained; hardly a household lacks an ex-prisoner in it. Many families have several members with prison experience. Thousands have been imprisoned more than once; and almost all detainees experience torture.
Thus the current demand for amnesty is not simply about the 11,500 men and women still held. Palestinians say an amnesty would vindicate those hundreds of thousands arrested, interrogated, and tortured since 1967 and before that as well. One PLO source estimates that 200,000 Palestinians have direct prison experience. By the Israeli police's own accounting, as of last October a total of 105,725 have been held since the intifadah began in December 1987.
In October 1993, after PLO Chairman Yasser Arafat and Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin signed the accord, a mere 560 out of 13,000 political prisoners were released. The move received international press attention but did not satisfy the Palestinian population, which knew that most of those freed were within weeks of a scheduled release anyway; moreover the 560 (not 640 as announced by Israel) did not include special cases of old, sick, and female prisoners. Palestinians felt further insulted when they saw that the PLO had merely negotiated release of members of Fatah, the PLO party that Mr. Arafat heads.
Arafat's apparent inability to overcome personal and party biases and the PLO's weak negotiating power confronts Palestinians with unhappy realities as the Declaration of Principles is put to the test of implementation.
The issue of political prisoners has long been a major concern to Palestinians because those arrested represent their relentless struggle for statehood. Prisoners are heroes to their families; and prison experience is central to the resistance movement. Many who felt they were unjustly held or who suffered extreme hardship in prison became more committed to political resistance; some joined radical Islamic parties.
The heroism of the prisoners among Palestinians is heightened by the inhumane conditions in which the prisoners are held captive and the perceived false justice under which they are tried. Stories of detainees' endurance circulate through the population. Families of members of Hamas and other parties who might have thrown their weight behind the PLO leadership are increasingly disinclined to support it. One finds that those young rebels taking up arms against both Israel and their Palestinian partners are the brothers, sons, and close friends of the unjustly imprisoned.
PRISONERS' rights groups inside Israel and among Palestinians are working tirelessly, although with little success, for the release of those unjustly arrested and for improved prison conditions. Reports by international human rights organization repeatedly criticize the Israeli military for excessive use of force in interrogation and for subhuman conditions in the 21 prisons and detention centers where Palestinians are held. Israel has consistently flouted this censure and defied international conventions regarding prisoners' rights.
The ineffectiveness of outside pressure groups led to a prison-wide hunger strike in 1992 by the more than 14,000 Palestinians then held in Israeli jails and camps. Under immense pressure, Israeli authorities agreed to some of the demands and international attention waned.
But today, 17 months later, almost none of the terms agreed to have been met; moreover, rights activists report, conditions of Palestinian prisoners are worse than ever.
Ahmad Sayyad, director of the political prisoner's rights group Mandela Institute, based in the West Bank town of Ramallah, notes the lack of progress with dismay. Especially troubling are health conditions of prisoners. He reports that several deaths in detention occurred in recent months; and men who received bullet wounds and injuries before arrest are regularly held without medical attention.
Mr. Sayyad worries that with international attention now focused on political talks, prisoners have less protection than before. ``Outside concern for prisoners has fallen off since the accord; so have funds supporting human rights work inside the territories,'' he says.
This situation has deeper political repercussions, fueling disillusionment about the peace process.
Palestinians note that members of the United States Congress speak out on behalf of missing Israeli soldiers in Lebanon and of Israel's call for amnesty for 300 of their collaborators, while they see more delays regarding the Palestinian prisoners who, they charge, are now being held political hostages.
If those political prisoners' rights cannot be won in the early stages, what, Palestinians ask, are our chances for autonomy and democracy as the negotiations proceed? The Opinion/Essay Page welcomes manuscripts. Authors of articles will be notified by telephone. Authors of articles not accepted will be notified by postcard. Send manuscripts by mail to Opinions/Essays, One Norway Street, Boston, MA 02115, by fax to 617 -450-2317, or by Internet E-mail to OPED@RACHEL.CSPS.COM.