Just how experienced is a regulator's experience?(Read article summary)
Courts sometimes use a regulator's experience to justify rulings. Is that fair if there's no data to back up regulators' claims?
Roger L. Wollenberg/UPI/Newscom
A simple but effective trick the state uses to eliminate due process and violate individual rights is experience. What do I mean? The foundation of all regulatory “law” is the notion that any body of regulators created by Congress possess, by virtue of said creation, unlimited expertise and experience over whatever subjects they regulate. This regulatory “experience” creates a strong judicial presumption in favor of the regulator; the presumption of innocence and individual rights gives way to disproving the “experience” of the regulator.
I was reviewing a 2005 Federal Trade Commission case earlier. The details are unimportant. The Commission decided a certain activity was harmful to consumers. There was no empirical data to support this claim, but the reviewing court reasoned that data was unnecessary, because the Commission’s “experience” allowed it to instinctively know the challenged activity was bad. Ergo, it was the defendant’s burden to disprove the Commission’s experience, which of course it couldn’t. Victory to the FTC.
Regulatory “experience” is a strange type of patent. Most FTC members are, of course, antitrust lawyers. Their “expertise” derives largely from having graduated law school. Yet with an FTC commission in hand, they become authorities on health care, manufacturing, retailing, et al. There’s no mechanism for an accused individual or firm to dispute this “expertise,” because any such process would require the regulator himself to acknowledge he’s, in reality, not an expert. As Ralph Wiggum would say, “that’s unpossible!”
The Christian Science Monitor has assembled a diverse group of the best economy-related bloggers out there. Our guest bloggers are not employed or directed by the Monitor and the views expressed are the bloggers' own, as is responsibility for the content of their blogs. To contact us about a blogger, click here. To add or view a comment on a guest blog, please go to the blogger's own site by clicking on the link above.