Share this story
Close X
Switch to Desktop Site

What price victory for union coal miners as strike ends?

The United Mine Workers (UMW) may have won a strike after 73 days on picket lines in coalfields across the country, but serious problems remain for the union, its president, Sam Church, and its 160,000 rank-and-file members.

Most miners were not happy with the agreement but after 10 weeks of striking, financial reserves were running low; some talked about "voting from their pockets" in approving the new contract.

About these ads

While labor troubles were not entirely cleared away -- UMW construction workers remained on strike when miners prepared to return to work June 7 -- this was the situation:

* The long strike had cost miners an estimated $3,000 to $5,000 each. Traditionally, union members who strike over basic principles are willing to make such a sacrifice for a victory that preserves union jobs and strengthens their union. In the UMW situation, many rank-and-filers are far from convinced that their sacrifice of wages was justifiable.

* The UMW's strength in the coal industry has been slipping steadily. It now represents miners who dig only about 44 percent of all coal produced; the remainder comes from nonunion mines. The new agreement is supposed to reinforce the union's position, but some in the industry and union predict a further growth of nonunion operations in more mechanized mines and in open-pit and strip mines. The UMW now faces aggressive organizing among nonunion miners who are likely to be more reluctant to join the union because of its long strike.

* Mr. Church faces reelection in 1982. He has made powerful enemies in the union in attempting to win a new contract this year without a strike. He lost and will undoubtedly face strong opposition next year.

* The coal industry, while it finally gained ground on issues that it had placed high on its list of bargaining demands, demonstrated that a UMW strike can be weathered successfully by the operators and, more critically, by the national economy. The long walkout may have proved a serious setback to UMW bargaining power. Some in the industry already are talking of a new strategy of building up huge coal reserves and taking UMW strikes triennially instead of engaging in "giveaway" negotiations with the union. If this attitude spreads, a hoped-for improvement in relations between the coal industry and the UMW would appear to be doomed.

Follow Stories Like This
Get the Monitor stories you care about delivered to your inbox.