Menu
Share
Share this story
Close X
 
Switch to Desktop Site

Still unsettled about a settlement

There's one born every minute, and my minute took place after the phone rang in the fall of 1984.

On the line: a Prudential salesman who told me about a great "investment" opportunity.

About these ads

We met, and I agreed to pay $300 or so every three months for a whole life insurance policy. After all, I was told, I could retire comfortably by signing on the dotted line. At the time, I was fresh out of college. (What was I thinking?)

About a year later, I woke up and realized that someone age 22 and just starting out on a career path does not need life insurance.

I let the policy lapse. End of story? Not yet. A few years later my name was added to a class-action suit against Prudential related to deceptive sales practices. I was $1,200 in the hole, and hoped to recoup some of that money.

Finally, in 1997, the company agreed to pay $2.6 billion to settle the suit. I never saw a dime.

My benefit from all this legal work was the opportunity to buy securities through Prudential at a discount. Own another piece of the rock? I wanted to throw one.

Plenty of people have reaped such "rewards" from a class-action suit. A co-worker received $1.48 from Providian after a class-action case involving high-interest credit cards. She also got $6 from Carnival, after the cruise line settled a lawsuit over inflated port fees.

No doubt class-action suits punish naughty firms and may lead them to treat customers better. But many customers who were burned may still be steaming.

About these ads

Now, as our lead story explains, a whole new round of class-action suits related to securities fraud has begun. Will investors recoup their losses? Perhaps some will.

But don't hold your breath.


Follow Stories Like This
Get the Monitor stories you care about delivered to your inbox.