Exclusive: Cyberattack leaves natural gas pipelines vulnerable to sabotage
A government report says a cyberattack against 23 natural gas pipeline operators stole crucial information that could compromise security. Experts strongly suspect China's military.
Cyberspies linked to Chinaâ€™s military targeted nearly two dozen US natural gas pipeline operators over a recent six-month period, stealing information that could be used to sabotage US gas pipelines, according to a restricted US government report and a source familiar with the government investigation.
From December 2011 through June 2012, cyberspies targeted 23 gas pipeline companies with e-mails crafted to deceive key personnel into clicking on malicious links or file attachments that let the attackers slip into company networks, says the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) report.
The report does not mention China, but the digital signatures of the attacks have been identified by independent cybersecurity researchers as belonging to a particular espionage group recently linked to Chinaâ€™s military.
The confluence of these factors â€“ Â along with the sensitive operational and technical details that were stolen â€“ make the cyberbreaches perhaps among the most serious so far, some experts say. The stolen information could give an adversary all the insider knowledge necessary to blow up not just a few compressor stations but perhaps many of them simultaneously, effectively holding the nationâ€™s gas infrastructure hostage. Nearly 30 percent of the nationâ€™s power grid now relies on natural gas generation.
â€śThis theft of key information is about hearing the footsteps get closer and closer,â€ť says William Rush, a retired scientist formerly with the Gas Technology Institute who chaired the effort to create a cybersecurity standard applicable to the gas pipeline industry.
â€śAnyone can blow up a gas pipeline with dynamite. But with this stolen information, if I wanted to blow up not one, but 1,000 compressor stations, I could,â€ť he adds. â€śI could put the attack vectors in place, let them sit there for years, and set them all off at the same time. I donâ€™t have to worry about getting people physically in place to do the job, I just pull the trigger with one mouse click.â€ť
The report comes at a time of growing US-China tensions over cyberespionage. President Obama called for tighter cybersecurity of critical US infrastructure in his State of the Union speech. This month, the White House also released an executive order that attempts to bolster cybersecurity among agencies that regulate electric utilities and other key industries. Congress, however, continues to resist legislation to mandate that such companies meet specific cybersecurity performance standards.
The attacks chronicled in the new DHS report were first reported in an exclusive Monitor article in May 2012, but the report offers confirmation, as well as further details and insights. Of the natural-gas pipeline operators targeted, 10 were infiltrated, another 10 cases are still being investigated, and three were â€śnear misses,â€ť in which the companies narrowly avoided infiltration of their networks, according to the report, titled â€śActive Cyber Campaigns Against the US Energy Sectorâ€ť and compiled by DHSâ€™s Industrial Control Systems Cyber Emergency Response Team (ICS-CERT).
What was stolen
Sensitive files were stolen that could give a cyberintruder the ability to control, or alter the operation of the pipelines, including usernames, passwords, personnel lists, system manuals, and pipeline control system access credentials, the report says.
â€śThe data exfiltrated could provide an adversary with the capability to access US [oil and natural gas industrial-control systems], including performing unauthorized operations,â€ť the report concludes. The stolen files were part of a â€śsophisticated attack shopping list.â€ť
According to a source familiar with the DHS investigation, hackers could use the data to directly reset computer-controlled pipeline systems, sabotaging them through extreme pipeline pressures or unsafe valve settings that could result in explosions or other critical failures.
â€śThese are not children or politically motivated hackers upset with someoneâ€™s rhetorical position on something,â€ť says the individual, who was not permitted to speak to the press and so requested anonymity. â€śThese are educated, motivated, well-funded operatives â€“ and theyâ€™re working toward something specific. If they exfiltrate credentials, they can log back in as system-level users and do whatever they want â€¦ even blow something up.â€ť
The cyberspies installed custom malware to search pipeline companiesâ€™ networks for any computer files with the letters â€śSCAD,â€ť which stand for supervisory control and data acquisition (SCADA). These are the special computerized control systems that software companies create to monitor and operate natural gas pipeline pumping stations, valves, communications, and other systems. Files the malware found and stole are just the sort of information necessary for an attacker to locate and operate compressors, valves, switches, pressure settings, and other pipeline operations, says Robert Huber, a cybersecurity expert at Critical Intelligence, a control-system security firm based in Idaho Falls, Idaho.
For example, among 28 computer files stolen from the gas pipeline operatorsâ€™ networks were lists of dialup modem access numbers for critical devices called RTUs, which are scattered across miles of pipeline and give operators the ability to monitor and control their networks â€“ including pipeline pressure. This is the greatest concern to Dr. Rush.
â€śIf you can use this information to reset things â€“ either equipment or the pipelineâ€™s control system â€“ thatâ€™s a serious penetration,â€ť he says. â€śIf youâ€™re getting dialup access information to the RTUs through the phone lines, thatâ€™s the one thatâ€™s pretty scary, very serious.â€ť
Natural gas pipelines are crucial to national security, says John Bumgarner, research director for the US Cyber Consequences Unit, a nonprofit group that studies cyberattacks.
â€śThe natural gas pipeline industry is near the top of the US critical infrastructure list, so of course they would be a military target,â€ť he says. â€śThe Chinese would want to get in and understand how the system communicates, how it works, and everything else. Yes, itâ€™s also about gathering business intelligence to improve processes in a foreign country. But those same digital pathways could also be used as a jumping off point for an attack.â€ť
The new link to China comes from the â€śindicators of compromiseâ€ť reported by DHS to the industry. Independent experts say these IOCs point to perpetrators who were identified earlier this month as being part of Chinaâ€™s Peopleâ€™s Liberation Army. The Feb. 19 report by Mandiant, a leading cybersecurity firm in Arlington, Va., traced attacks on 141 companies worldwide to â€śUnit 61398,â€ť which works out of a 12-story building in Shanghai.
â€śThe IOCs put out by Mandiant and the IOCs put out by ICS-CERT are the same as the IOCs involved in the natural gas pipelines,â€ť says the person familiar with the investigation.
Others researchers come to the same conclusion: All signs point to Unit 61398, which has also been dubbed â€śAPT1â€ť and â€śComment Crew.â€ť
â€śWith the gas-pipeline attacks, we know those indicators are associated with APT1,â€ť says Mr. Huber of Critical Intelligence. â€śWeâ€™ve seen this group operating before.â€ťÂ Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â Â
Chinese government officials reject accusations that cyberspies connected to its military have scooped up gigabytes of stolen data from pipeline companies. Chinaâ€™s embassy in Washington did not respond to e-mailed requests for comment by press time. But a spokesman contacted by the Monitor earlier this month rejected Mandiantâ€™s assertions.
â€śCyber attacks are transnational and anonymous. Determining their origins is extremely difficult. We don't know how the evidence in this so-called report can be tenable,â€ť Geng Shuang, spokesman at the Chinese Embassy in Washington said in an e-mailed statement. â€śChinese laws prohibit cyber attacks and China has done what it can to combat such activities in accordance with Chinese laws and regulations.â€ť
Is it all about 'fracking'?
DHS officials refused to comment on the source of the attacks or answer a list of e-mailed questions, but they noted that the Department actively works with the private sector during cyberincidents to create â€śsituational awareness.
â€śProtecting critical infrastructure against growing and evolving cyberthreats requires a layered approach,â€ť DHS spokesman Peter Boogaard said in a statement. The agency actively works with companies â€śto improve the security and resilience of critical infrastructureâ€ť and in â€śmitigating the impacts of attempted disruptions to the Nationâ€™s critical cyber and communications networks.â€ť
So far, there is no evidence that America's natural gas pipelines have been sabotaged. But experts say China could have a more immediate interest in natural-gas data beyond the longer-term threat of a theoretical cyberwar. The cyberspies are aiming mainly at stealing technology related to hydraulic fracturing or â€śfrackingâ€ť of shale to extract natural gas, says Mr. Huber of Critical Intelligence.
Stealing industrial secrets about fracking could help energy-starved China develop its own technologies to mine natural gas without having to buy equipment or expertise from abroad.
Natural gas pipeline industry officials are concerned.
â€śOur industry takes these threats seriously and continues to work with ICS-CERT and other agencies to ensure security,â€ť says Cathy Landry, a spokesman for the Interstate Natural Gas Association of America. â€śIt was serious before, itâ€™s serious now. When youâ€™re dealing with cybersecurity, itâ€™s just as important as a physical threat.â€ť
Attacks hit suppliers, too
In addition to attacks on pipeline operators, cyberspies have also targeted suppliers of crucial control-system technologies. One notable company highlighted in the DHS report as having been hacked is Telvent Canada, which has a huge footprint in the oil and gas industry â€“ and a key role in the emerging â€śsmart gridâ€ť that more efficiently coordinates energy distribution. Its software allows old and new software to speak to each other â€“ and control critical systems.
If captured, the source code from such a product could be used to far more easily develop potent cyberweapons akin toÂ Stuxnet, a hyper-sophisticated software weapon reported to have destroyed 1,000 or more Iranian nuclear centrifuges.
"The attackers used their presence on the Telvent network to download the customer project files for a future attack â€“ think future Stuxnet," Dale Peterson, a control system security experts wrote in his blog. "If an attacker were going to attack a process in a sophisticated manner they would need time and talent to study the project files and essentially reverse engineer the process."
As with the pipeline hacks, the source of the Telvent attacks appears to be Unit 61398.
â€śYes, we have indicators that match Telventâ€ť to other hacks traced to Unit 61398, Huber writes in an e-mail. â€śSo yes, same group likely.â€ť