Menu
Share
Share this story
Close X
 
Switch to Desktop Site

A Thanksgiving gratitude: Thank you for caring for my homeless brother

A sister's ode to her homeless brother, who passed on in New York City, just a few days before Thanksgiving.

View video

People walk past a homeless man – not Adam Goldenthal - asking for money on 14th Street in New York on Sept. 4, 2015.

(AP Photo/Mary Altaffer)

View photo

Around the holidays, the news media tends to focus on the homeless, but not from the perspective of the families who have lost them to the streets.

My brother Adam Goldenthal’s life ended a few days ago at age 45 in a cold subway stairwell in New York City, where he fell asleep for the last time. He was found "as if he was sleeping" on “a nest of flattened cardboard boxes” according to the NYPD detective with whom I spoke. (Was it the years of smoking, alcohol abuse, or living rough? The coroner won’t know for sure for weeks.)

About these ads

It sounded so peaceful as the nightmare stereotype came true. I had always prayed this wouldn't be the way he died – alone and cold on cardboard. I had hoped for at least a hospital bed or shelter. I dreamed of him being well, able to be with family here in Virginia or in New Jersey with our mom.

I had to ask my husband to Photoshop the only image I have of Adam to hide the bruises and stitches visible on his face after a fight in a shelter last year so I could have something for the obituary and memorial service.

That kind of thing comes with the hidden territory of the families of the homeless. If they are called the “invisible people,” we are called nothing at all, if we’re fortunate, or by cruel names by the uninformed. People think we abandoned our loved ones. They think we turned our backs and don't care. It may be true for some, but not for any I've ever met.

Adam was diagnosed bipolar, alcoholic, and had lived on the streets for the better part of the past five years, when not jailed for minor crimes.

During this time, there were many different iterations of Adam.

To clientele at the Starbucks and Barnes & Noble in Times and Union Squares, Adam was that funny homeless guy who played gorgeous classical and jazz guitar while puffing an unfiltered Camel cigarette.

To police, EMTs, ER security guards, social workers, shelter staff, and transit police, my brother was that often witty homeless guy who went off at the drop of a hat, spewing obscenities and spinning wild, paranoid delusional tales as he went down swinging at the world he couldn’t fit into.

About these ads

To my 85-year-old mother and me, he was someone we loved too much to walk away from, but who frequently took aim at us both physically and verbally during manic episodes. Then, he was terribly sorry.

We prayed for God to grant him peace, but when that peace came it took too finite a form.

There is only one road to peace for me now and it comes with this opportunity to give thanks to all of those who were able to help my brother when I couldn’t.

I am thankful for every person who ever cooked a meal at a shelter, set up the cots, and cleaned up the messes.

For the police, transit, and security officers who dealt with him often enough to know he had been diagnosed with a heart condition and chose not to taser him when he attacked because they would rather take a hit than kill him, I give thanks.

Every police operator, dispatcher, ER, and shelter staff person who ever took time to call me with updates has my undying gratitude for giving me and my mother the precious gift of knowing he was alive.

Mostly, I want to let every single person who ever dropped change into his guitar case, let him use their cell phone to call me, or bought him a cup of coffee to know that they did something valuable.

You, the givers, are my inspiration. I have always freely handed money, food, and time to every homeless person who crossed my path because I knew you were there crossing his. He told me about every dime, smile, and sip.

Every time we give, both the homeless person and their family members are uplifted. While giving to my brother couldn’t save him, it fed our humanity, our sanity, and our hopes, which is a big thing for a little spare change.

While our family is smaller this holiday season, it is bigger with all of you as honorary members. Thank you. 


Follow Stories Like This
Get the Monitor stories you care about delivered to your inbox.