America, the service industry?(Read article summary)
America isn't a country that can survive by offering services. It need to make – and sell – things.
Miserable cities…ghost towns…angry voters…
The Dow was flat yesterday. Gold rose $2. And Greece said it was making progress towards cutting its deficit.
Yesterday we looked at America’s most miserable cities. Today, let’s take a gander at its new “ghost towns.”
There are many towns and cities that are losing population…losing key industries…and probably on the verge of extinction. USA Today mentioned some of them in a cover story this Tuesday.
Ravenswood, W. Va., for example. It has 4,000 people and one major business. It’s a one-horse town, in other words, and the nag is leaving. The aluminum works are partly shuttered already, says USA Today; the rest is for sale.
What’s going to happen to Ravenswood? It could become a ghost town.
There are already dozens of towns in West Virginia that are inhabited mostly by ghosts. They’re relics of the booms and busts of the past. Mining, logging, railroads – each one created it own towns. Then, the profitable industries of the 19th and 20th century became unprofitable somewhere along the line. People left. Those who remain live among the shades.
“In the America where things are made the recession has a depression,” continues the report. “According to a new Northeastern University study, one in every six blue-collar industrial jobs have disappeared since 2007.”
And one in five adult males of prime working age is out of work. There are fewer and fewer factory towns in the US…and fewer and fewer jobs for people who work in them. And now comes word that auto sales in February fell nearly 4%. And early estimates suggest that the job report coming tomorrow will be depressing.
“Industrial workers are dinosaurs,” says one laid-off worker, now retraining to be a traveling nurse.
Hmmm… Let’s see. How does this work? No one makes anything anymore. We all become service industry workers…looking out for one another. I give you $5 for cutting my lawn. You give me $5 for cutting your hair. Neither of us has a penny more. How then do we afford to buy anything?
“An industrial town makes products that bring wealth into a community; a post-industrial ghost town as a zero-sum economy – people in marginal jobs ‘serving and paying each other,’” says USA Today.
Services don’t make people wealthier. They may make them more comfortable. But real prosperity requires real stuff – food, cars, tables, light bulbs, iPads.
Of course, you could offer services to people who make these things. A small nation, such as Singapore, for example, could earn a living by offering financial services. A Caribbean island could offer vacations. But what can a great nation like the US offer? It can’t get by on services. And it can’t support half its population on welfare, unemployment and food stamps. It needs manufacturing…it needs to make things…and sell them.
Why doesn’t it do that already? How come so many people are out of work? How come men can find jobs?
Ooh la la…too many questions. But when was the last time you heard a mother proudly announce that her son was going into manufacturing? Or that he was learning to be a machinist? When was the last time you saw a major factory under construction? When was the last time you picked up something in a shop, turned it over and found “Made in America” stamped on the underside?
The Christian Science Monitor has assembled a diverse group of the best economy-related bloggers out there. Our guest bloggers are not employed or directed by the Monitor and the views expressed are the bloggers' own, as is responsibility for the content of their blogs. To contact us about a blogger, click here. To add or view a comment on a guest blog, please go to the blogger's own site by clicking on the link above.