City budgets set to get worse, 'tough decisions' ahead
The National League of Cities report released Tuesday suggests cities will have to get more innovative – perhaps privatizing important municipal functions.
Jeff Hayne/ Reuters/ File
Despite recent headlines that suggest the recession is on the wane, the worst is still ahead for American cities, according to a report issued Tuesday.
The annual survey of the National League of Cities in Washington reports that 89 percent of city finance officers say they doubt that their city budget will be able to meet fiscal needs in 2010, which report authors say is the worst outlook the survey has reported in 24 years. Municipalities of every size are expected to struggle to fill budget gaps through 2011, the report says.
Declines in income and sales taxes, as well as falling property taxes, are challenging cities' ability to provide basic services.
“We’re in a period where a lot of local governments have to make tough decisions about the service they provide, and how to raise revenue to fund these service, and what they want the community to look like going forward,” says Chris Hoene, co-author of the report.
The report is based upon data from 379 cities with populations ranging from under 50,000 to over 300,000. The study is not comprehensive, though. For example, Detroit, which is suffering from a $250 million deficit and faces the possibility of receivership in the fall, was not included.
Yet the report has enough cities “to represent what is happening nationally,” Mr. Hoene says.
The average budget gap is expected to reach 2.9 percent by the end of this year, with spending is forecast to increase 2.5 percent and revenues to fall 0.4 percent.
The downturn in the real estate market, which once provided additional income to boost consumer confidence, is the chief culprit for the growing budget gaps during the next two years. Assessments have yet to reflect the full market drop.
Hoene says cities are coping with the shortfalls in different ways:
• Forty-five percent are increasing fees.
• Twenty-seven percent are creating new fees for existing services.
• About 25 percent increased property taxes this year.
• Sixty-seven percent are making layoffs.
Yet Hoene says cities must use the crisis as a way to rethink how city services are provided, which includes privatization, partnerships between the public and private sectors, and more involvement with nonprofits and citizens.
They must “set some priorities about what is important” and at what expense, he says.
The long-term effect of the current predicament is that local government will become more willing to involve outside parties to defray costs.
“Any organization, public, private, or non-for-profit, that has an idea that will help local governments save money and provide a service will be welcome and well received at city halls around the country,” says Hoene. “We’re in a time where crisis will probably help innovation."
The perils of city outsourcing
Chicago has lead the way in selling or leasing city assets to defray costs. But the program has had its share of troubles.
Follow us on Twitter.